Subscribe Sign in

Health

Charles 'giddily elated' on night Diana was killed, her brother claims

ABC News
3 min read Rewritten in plain language

RoyaltyMental Health

Show what we removed Rules applied: A1 A4 C5 D1 D3×2 E3×2 all 30 rules
  • King Charles III has, for the second consecutive day, been the subject of bombshell allegations relating to his first wife, Princess Diana
  • Princess Diana's brother has accused King Charles III of sounding "giddily elated, like a lottery winner" on the night his ex-wife was killed in a car crash almost three decades ago.
  • Among several complaints about the royal family's behaviour at the time of his sister's death, Earl Spencer gave his account of the night of the 1997 crash.
  • Among several disparaging assertions, Earl Spencer alleged King Charles had told him "we'll forget her soon enough" in the days after Princess Diana was killed.
  • While Diana's deteriorating mental health, including a well-documented eating disorder, has been a matter of public knowledge for several years, Earl Spencer's direct and personal attacks linking them to King Charles are new.

5 sentences from our version of the report, chosen to cover it. Nothing here is written; every line is in the article below. How

The claims continue a war of words between Earl Spencer and Buckingham Palace that erupted earlier this week. Princess Diana and King Charles divorced in 1996.

Headline check

All two things this headline claims are in the report.

Figures, names and quoted words in the headline, looked for in the report itself — not in the summary above. How this is checked

Read the full reportHide the full report3 min

King Charles III has, for the second consecutive day, been the subject of bombshell allegations relating to his first wife, Princess Diana

Among them is the assertion that he sounded "elated" on the night she was killed.

The claims were made by Diana's brother, Charles Spencer, in his soon-to-be-released book.

Princess Diana's brother has accused King Charles III of sounding "giddily elated, like a lottery winner" on the night his ex-wife was killed in a car crash almost three decades ago.

The explosive claim came in Charles Spencer's soon-to-be-released memoir, Swan Song: Diana, My Sister, an excerpt of which Britain's Daily Mail published on Thursday, local time.

Among several complaints about the royal family's behaviour at the time of his sister's death, Earl Spencer gave his account of the night of the 1997 crash.

"Unlike my other callers, who were stunned, barely able to articulate their condolences and offers of help, he [Charles] sounded giddily elated — like a lottery winner, I remember thinking at the time," the excerpt read.

"He let me know he had informed William and Harry of their mother's death, first thing that morning, in their bedrooms at Balmoral. It all sounded matter-of-fact, given the enormity of the disaster.

"Looking back now, I suspect the prince's first reaction must have been to think more of how this event might free him to marry the woman he loved, rather than appreciating the loss of one he did not. It can be hard to feel too much sympathy for an ex-spouse, or those who care for them profoundly, after bitter divorce."

The claims continue a war of words between Earl Spencer and Buckingham Palace that erupted earlier this week, when the first details of the book were made public.

Among several disparaging assertions, Earl Spencer alleged King Charles had told him "we'll forget her soon enough" in the days after Princess Diana was killed.

In response, a palace spokesperson said: "While we do not comment on books as a matter of principle, His Majesty is mindful that the pain of fraternal grief can cloud reason, affect judgement and colour memory in ways others do not recognise, even many years after such a loss."

Royal commentators have described the rebuke as the most pointed statement they had seen from a British monarch in years.

Buckingham Palace is yet to respond to Earl Spencer's latest claims.

Princess Diana and King Charles — who was not on the throne at the time — divorced in 1996. Charles married Queen Camilla, with whom he had been having a long-running affair, in 2005.

The extract of Earl Spencer's book released on Thursday included several bombshell allegations, including that:

While Diana's deteriorating mental health, including a well-documented eating disorder, has been a matter of public knowledge for several years, Earl Spencer's direct and personal attacks linking them to King Charles are new.

The claims he makes in it have continued a period for the royal family, which has included a public and ongoing rift between the king's two sons, William and Harry, as well as a police investigation into the monarch's brother, Andrew, who has been accused of child sex offences, which he denies.

In the past two years, Charles has also been treated for an undisclosed type of cancer, as has his daughter-in-law, Princess Catherine, who has recovered.

"It is only going to get worse; this is one extract that's being released from the book next week. One. I mean whatever else is in there is going to be explosive," royal commentator Afua Hagan told the ABC.

"Buckingham Palace is definitely going to be in damage control, and they have to be because Charles Spencer has always been so loyal to Princess Diana in her life and in her death, and he has really kept it in for a long time — all these things he has wanted to say."

Earl Spencer's book is expected to be released next week.

You are reading our version, not theirs. This is ABC News's report with its verdicts and loaded words taken out. Plain description stays, and so do adjectives that carry a fact, such as "former" or "federal". The reporting, the facts and the quotations are theirs — quotations are never edited — and the indicators beside it measure this version. Hover or tap Adjectives to see every one left in the text.

How outlets headlined it

Each outlet's own headline. Struck through: the loaded words our version leaves out. Plainest first.

  • ABC News Charles 'giddily elated' on night Diana was killed, her brother claims plain
  • The Age ‘Like a lottery winner’: Charles ‘elated’ after Diana’s death, her brother’s new book claims plain
  • The West Australian King Charles ‘sounded giddily elated’ after Princess Diana’s death, brother Earl Spencer claims in new book plain

How this outlet filed it, and how we rewrote it

No other newsroom we read has filed on this event, so there is nothing to compare it with yet.

Also covered by The Age, Brisbane Times, WAtoday, The Sydney Morning Herald, The West Australian. We hold only their summary of it, not the report, so there is nothing of theirs to measure here.

Outlet Niral ScoreAdjectivesSourcingSentimentHappiness
ABC Newsas they published this story 10.3 8 77 -0.8 26.9
Mundane Readneutralized from ABC News 5.4 7 77 -0.6 38.7

Sign in to react.

This story is about a death. Comments are closed on those, because the people closest to it are among the people who read them. If something here is wrong, tell us — that we do read.

The same event elsewhere

5 other outlets filed this story. The scoreboard above is what they did differently.