Subscribe Sign in

Sport / Brisbane, QLD

Brisbane snatch victory from Hawthorn in all-time classic AFL preliminary final

5 min read Live blog A running feed, still being written. Rewritten in plain language

AFLHawthornBrisbane LionsSport

Changed after publishing · 1 edit
  • the headline was changed: Hawthorn Hawks v Brisbane Lions: snatch victory from Hawthorn in all-time classic AFL preliminary final– live

Outlets edit stories after they go out, usually without saying so. We keep what we saw the first time.

Show what we removed Rules applied: A1 A3×2 A4×2 C2 D2×9 D3×16 D4×2 E3×3 F2×4 all 30 rules
  • Updates as the Hawks host the reigning premiers at the MCG
  • Fremantle have already booked their ticket to a second AFL grand final after storming over the top of Sydney in a preliminary final last night.
  • The Fremantle Football Club have never had a night like this.
  • Brisbane were quick to bounce back as they brushed aside their horror qualifying final defeat to Sydney with a commanding win against Adelaide.
  • For all of their recent success, the Hawks and the Lions meet for the first time in a final since 1986 when the latter were still under the Fitzroy banner and yet to merge with the Brisbane Bears.

5 sentences from our version of the report, chosen to cover it. Nothing here is written; every line is in the article below. How

This is a live blog: a running feed the outlet is still writing. We measure how it is written, but we do not summarise or rewrite it. Follow it at The Guardian Australia (Sport).

Headline check

The one thing this headline claims is in the report.

Figures, names and quoted words in the headline, looked for in the report itself — not in the summary above. One claim in this headline could be checked, so this is a narrow pass and not a thorough one. How this is checked

Read the full reportHide the full report5 min

Updates as the Hawks host the reigning premiers at the MCG

Hawthorn and Brisbane meet with a grand final spot on the line. Fremantle have already booked their ticket to a second AFL grand final after storming over the top of Sydney in a preliminary final last night. Jonathan Horn was at the SCG to watch the Dockers turn the tables with the last six goals of the game against the undermanned Swans.

The Fremantle Football Club have never had a night like this. They’ve never been forced this deep down the well to win a big game. They’ve never had so much thrown at them. They’ve never been in such a hostile environment. They’ve never, in a big game, flipped so quickly from a meek, nervy, fumbly team to an offensive powerhouse.

FB: 6 James Sicily, 37 Tom Barrass, 15 Blake Hardwick HB: 10 Karl Amon, 4 Jarman Impey, 24 Josh Battle C: 1 Harry Morrison, 12 Will Day, 16 Massimo D’Ambrosio HF: 8 Dylan Moore, 18 Mabior Chol, 33 Jack Ginnivan FF: 5 Nick Watson, 2 Mitch Lewis, 19 Jack Gunston FOLL: 17 Lloyd Meek, 3 Jai Newcombe, 25 Josh Ward INT: 23 Josh Weddle, 42 Bailey Macdonald, 28 Cam Mackenzie, 9 Connor Macdonald, 40 Max Beattie

FB: 22 Ty Gallop, 31 Harris Andrews, 35 Ryan Lester HB: 3 Jaspa Fletcher, 27 Darcy Gardiner, 15 Dayne Zorko C: 7 Jarrod Berry, 6 Hugh McCluggage, 33 Zac Bailey HF: 23 Charlie Cameron, 13 Logan Morris, 26 Conor McKenna FF: 30 Eric Hipwood, 16 Cam Rayner, 1 Kai Lohmann FOLL: 2 Sam Draper, 5 Josh Dunkley, 9 Lachie Neale INT: 32 Darcy Fort, 44 Darcy Wilmot, 8 Will Ashcroft, 10 Levi Ashcroft, 4 Oscar Allen

Brisbane were quick to bounce back as they brushed aside their horror qualifying final defeat to Sydney with a commanding win against Adelaide. Jonathan Horn was suitably impressed – but far from surprised – by the way the Lions responded.

After 106 games in four years, one can still never be sure whether the good Brisbane or the bad Brisbane will turn up on any given day. But all they need is a runway of a few weeks. All they need is a kick up the backside, a big occasion, a packed MCG and a cutthroat final. They played some of their best football against Hawthorn in August, have a good record against them in the Fagan era, and relish playing on their home ground. A lot is made of the coach’s little hooks – to run towards the fire, to dance on ice, to charge the opposition Braveheart style. All of them are another way of saying “embrace risk”. But all of them are dependent on the little girl with the little curl.

The Hawks and Lions players have been out on the MCG warming up before 90,000+ fans descend.

There’s long stretches where he won’t be sighted. But he’s always the dominant presence on the field. He’s the Hawthorn player who gets in the opposition’s head, whether it’s the defender seeking to exit without being mown down, or the match committee preparing for a game. A fortnight ago, Fremantle opted for the insurance policy of Brandon Walker, who hadn’t played since early March. Walker was picked for his speed, and he performed. But he was unable to mitigate the Watson moments. The first came when Walker momentarily lost contact with him, Watson motored in on his blind spot, parted a pack of Dockers, and volleyed a goal at full pelt. No one else in Australia could have kicked that goal. No one else would have even attempted it. And no one could have stopped him.

Final teams are in with no late changes.

Hawthorn named an unchanged lineup from the 23 that impressed with an ambush of Fremantle in their qualifying final at Optus Stadium.

Brisbane resisted the urge to recall Noah Answerth after he contained Nick Watson the last time these two sides met, with the defender still sidelined with an ankle injury. That allows Ty Gallop to retain his spot after he made the most of his opportunity in the semi-final win against Adelaide.

Hello and welcome to live coverage of the AFL preliminary final between Hawthorn and Brisbane at the MCG. The winner of this game will face Fremantle in the AFL grand final at the MCG next Saturday.

Hawthorn have been able to sit back and watch as all but two other teams have dropped out of contention since their rollicking qualifying final victory against the Dockers. As the final siren sealed that rousing triumph on the road, the widely held view was that Sam Mitchell’s side would avoid meeting Brisbane until a possible grand final matchup. But a finals series, if ever, follows the script – and here we are, a week earlier than forecast, with the Hawks instead crossing paths with the two-time reigning premiers for a spot in the decider.

The Hawks have quietly become the form side of the competition with only one defeat – and a draw – in their past eight matches. Though that loss was one they would prefer to forget as they were affected by a certain team from the sunshine state.

Brisbane roared back to life with a commanding win against Adelaide in a semi-final, after dishing up one of their all-too common listless performances against an undermanned Sydney a week earlier. The Lions have shown over several years that as much as they can fail to show up for a game here and there, they are just capable of rising as the stakes do. And the path they have ended up on is much the same as the past two years, when they won Saturday twilight preliminary finals at the MCG and went on to win back-to-back flags.

The Lions are now two wins away from sealing a premiership three-peat, and becoming just the third side in almost seven decades to claim as many flags in successive seasons. The previous two were of course the Hawks in 2013-15 and the Lions themselves in 2001-03.

For all of their recent success, the Hawks and the Lions meet for the first time in a final since 1986 when the latter were still under the Fitzroy banner and yet to merge with the Brisbane Bears. First ball-up will be at 5.15pm in Melbourne / AEST. I’ll drop in the team news shortly. Meanwhile, shoot me an email with your thoughts and predictions. Let’s get into it!

You are reading our version, not theirs. This is The Guardian Australia (Sport)'s report with its verdicts and loaded words taken out. Plain description stays, and so do adjectives that carry a fact, such as "former" or "federal". The reporting, the facts and the quotations are theirs — quotations are never edited — and the indicators beside it measure this version. Hover or tap Adjectives to see every one left in the text.

How outlets headlined it

Each outlet's own headline. Struck through: the loaded words our version leaves out. Plainest first.

  • The Guardian Australia (Sport) Brisbane snatch victory from Hawthorn in all-time classic AFL preliminary final plain
  • The Guardian Australia (Sport) AFL finals: where the Hawthorn v Brisbane preliminary final will be won and lost | Martin Pegan plain
  • The Age Dockers surge into grand final plain
  • The West Australian AFL Finals: Brisbane Lions to play Fremantle Dockers in grand final plain

How each outlet filed it

Also covered by The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald, WAtoday, Brisbane Times, The West Australian. We hold only their summary of it, not the report, so there is nothing of theirs to measure here.

Outlet Niral ScoreAdjectivesSentimentHappiness
The Guardian Australia (Sport)as they published this story 18 29 0 41.3
The Guardian Australia (Sport) 17.7 30 -0.3 51
Mundane Readneutralized from The Guardian Australia (Sport) 13.8 26 -0.1 51

Sign in to react.

Comments

Nothing here yet.

Sign in to comment.

Questions

Readers can ask a question about this story here. Questions and answers are for subscribers. Sign in to read them.

Comments are read before they appear where anything in them needs a person to look. Nothing posted here is ever deleted; a comment taken down keeps its text and the reason, so the decision can be looked at again. How this works

The same event elsewhere

6 other outlets filed this story. The scoreboard above is what they did differently.