Subscribe Sign in

Courts

Shackling prisoners giving birth should be a last resort – but it’s happening around Australia anyway

1 min read Rewritten in plain language

PrisonsIndigenous IncarcerationWomenIndigenous AustraliansHuman Rights

Show what we removed Rules applied: A1 C2 C5 D2×4 D3×4 D4 E3 all 30 rules
  • Senator Lidia Thorpe has introduced a bill to prohibit the practice in Australian prisons that advocates say violates the human rights of both mother and child.
  • Lidia Thorpe, the Gunnai, Gunditjmara and Djab Wurrung woman and independent senator for Victoria, has introduced a private member’s bill to prohibit shackling during childbirth.
  • According to an August report from the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, about one in 10 of Australia’s prisoners are women.
  • The Australian College of Midwives has said it was also against the Mandela rules for the treatment of prisoners and shackling was “an unsafe and unnecessary practice that may result in adverse outcomes for women and newborns, perinatal mental ill-health”.

4 sentences from our version of the report, chosen to cover it. Nothing here is written; every line is in the article below. How

The only data on giving birth while incarcerated was from 2017.

Headline check

The one thing this headline claims is in the report.

Figures, names and quoted words in the headline, looked for in the report itself — not in the summary above. One claim in this headline could be checked, so this is a narrow pass and not a thorough one. How this is checked

Senator Lidia Thorpe has introduced a bill to prohibit the practice in Australian prisons that advocates say violates the human rights of both mother and child.

Isaac says officers handcuffed her fellow prisoner in the back of a van and took her away.

In her submission to a federal inquiry into shackling during childbirth, she says many woman who have experienced it “still think about the time they gave birth to their child cuffed to the bed, years later”.

Lidia Thorpe, the Gunnai, Gunditjmara and Djab Wurrung woman and independent senator for Victoria, has introduced a private member’s bill to prohibit shackling during childbirth.

On Wednesday, Thorpe told the Senate about Heather Calgaret, a Yamatji, Noongar, Wongi and Pitjantjatjara woman, and mother of four children.

In 2019, she gave birth while shackled to a hospital bed in Victoria.

According to an August report from the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, about one in 10 of Australia’s prisoners are women.

The only data on giving birth while incarcerated was from 2017, when 25 women gave birth.

Fifteen years ago, the UN general assembly adopted the Bangkok Rules on the treatment of female prisoners, which state that prison should be a last resort for pregnant women and that “instruments of restraint shall never be used on women during labour, during birth and immediately after birth”.

The Australian College of Midwives has said it was also against the Mandela rules for the treatment of prisoners and shackling was “an unsafe and unnecessary practice that may result in adverse outcomes for women and newborns, perinatal mental ill-health”.

Shortened to 1 minute of reading, this version reads 4.4 on the Niral Score.

You are reading our version, not theirs. This is The Guardian Australia's report shortened to its most important sentences, in plainer words, with verdicts and loaded words taken out. Plain description stays, and so do adjectives that carry a fact, such as "former" or "federal". The reporting, the facts and the quotations are theirs — quotations are never edited — and the indicators beside it measure this version. Hover or tap Adjectives to see every one left in the text.

How this outlet filed it, and how we rewrote it

No other newsroom we read has filed on this event, so there is nothing to compare it with yet.

Outlet Niral ScoreAdjectivesSourcingSentimentHappiness
The Guardian Australiaas they published this story 10.4 4 80 -0.1 43.8
Mundane Readneutralized from The Guardian Australia 9.8 3 80 -0.1 43.8

Sign in to react.

Comments

Nothing here yet.

Sign in to comment.

Questions

Readers can ask a question about this story here. Questions and answers are for subscribers. Sign in to read them.

Comments are read before they appear where anything in them needs a person to look. Nothing posted here is ever deleted; a comment taken down keeps its text and the reason, so the decision can be looked at again. How this works